Tax planning guide

W-2 Offer vs Contractor Compensation: Compare Cash, Time and Benefits

Compare the actual calendar-year W-2 pay with contractor receipts based on realistic billable hours, then subtract each alternative's own cash costs and modeled taxes. Keep retirement assets and independently entered noncash benefit values separate from spendable cash. A higher contract rate is not automatically a better offer, and this comparison does not determine whether a worker may legally be classified as a contractor.

Build two alternatives for the same year, not two sources on one return

This example compares a full-year employee offer with a mutually exclusive full-year sole-proprietor offer. It does not combine the wages with contractor earnings or consume one alternative's Social Security wage base with the other. A midyear transition, concurrent employment, spouse income or another business requires a different return-level calculation.

  • Use actual calendar-year salary, or an hourly employee rate multiplied by explicitly entered paid hours and weeks. Do not prorate an already prorated annual salary again.
  • For the contractor, subtract unpaid and nonbillable weeks from the entered planning weeks. Hours per billable week exclude unpaid administration within those weeks. Do not count the same time twice.
  • Subtract actual same-year deductible cash business costs from receipts. Personal insurance and retirement contributions are not additional Schedule C expenses in this comparison.

Worked 2026 annual offer assumptions

Synthetic facts: single, age 40, full-year U.S. resident, standard deduction, no other household income, gains, credits, itemizing or special taxes. The contractor actively participates in one qualifying domestic non-SSTB sole proprietorship with no employees, QBI carryovers or special transactions. Insurance and plan deductions are independently verified assumptions, not eligibility determinations.

User-entered annual facts, not market-rate or benefit recommendations
FactW-2 alternativeContractor alternative
Pay$100,000 actual annual salary$75 per billable hour
Time40 hours per paid week; 52 paid weeks40 hours per billable week; 52 planning weeks less 4 unpaid and 2 nonbillable
Annual cash costs$1,000 nondeductible job costs; $3,000 after-tax insurance$8,000 fully deductible business costs; $9,000 insurance
Verified insurance deductionNone; insurance is after-tax$9,000 independently allowed
Retirement cash elections$10,000 pretax employee 401(k)$10,000 pretax solo employee plus $4,000 pretax employer
Additional employer / benefit amounts$4,000 vested employer retirement; $5,000 entered noncash benefit value$0 entered noncash benefit value

Follow profit through SE tax, adjustments and QBI

The contractor has 46 billable weeks, or 1,840 billable hours. Receipts of $138,000 less $8,000 business costs produce $130,000 net profit. Schedule SE net earnings are $120,055 after multiplying by 92.35%; the modeled SE tax is $18,368.42. Its half-SE adjustment is $9,184.2075 before display rounding, not a second cash tax payment.

Subtract the half-SE adjustment, $14,000 allowed pretax retirement contribution and $9,000 allowed health deduction to obtain AGI and QBI of $97,815.7925. The $16,100 standard deduction leaves $81,715.7925 before QBI; the applicable 20% taxable-income limit produces a $16,343.1585 QBI deduction. Taxable income is $65,372.634, with $9,093.98 modeled federal income tax. These calculations retain internal precision rather than repeatedly rounding intermediate adjustments.

Results rounded to cents; columns do not form one equivalent-salary score
Annual resultW-2 alternativeContractor alternative
Gross pay / receipts$100,000.00$138,000.00
Employee FICA / SE tax$7,650.00$18,368.42
Federal income tax before payments$10,970.00$9,093.98
Spendable cash after included taxes and entered cash costs$67,380.00$79,537.60
Retirement assets added, before future distribution tax$14,000.00$14,000.00
Independently entered noncash benefit value$5,000.00$0.00

Read the three outcomes separately

  • The contractor cash advantage in this synthetic example is $12,157.60. It is not a universal rate premium and excludes state/local taxes and every unsupported household fact.
  • The W-2 employer's $4,000 retirement contribution increases retirement assets, not spendable cash. Employee retirement elections reduce cash once; only allowed pretax amounts reduce income-tax bases. Roth elections, including required Roth catch-up, are not deductible.
  • The entered $5,000 employee benefit value is not cash, a tax deduction, an insurance recommendation or an objective valuation. Do not add it to a tax-deferred retirement balance and call the sum take-home pay.
  • Annual income-tax liability is different from withholding or quarterly payments. Publication 505 addresses payment timing; this example provides no safe-harbor, payment-calendar or penalty conclusion.
  • No break-even hourly rate is supplied. Changing a rate changes receipts, SE tax, adjustments, QBI and potentially contribution bounds, so dividing a cash gap by hours while holding tax fixed is unreliable.

Retirement and deduction boundaries before relying on an output

The workspace supports published 2025-2027 employer-401(k), traditional-SEP and solo-401(k) limits, not an IRA eligibility calculation. Notice 2026-66 supplies the 2027 $25,500 regular deferral, $8,500 ordinary catch-up or $11,750 instead at ages 60-63, $75,000 annual-additions cap before eligible catch-up and $375,000 compensation ceiling. Enter actual reviewed elections, not assumed maximum funding. Employer and employee ceilings are interdependent, including the self-employed deduction worksheet's remaining-compensation bound. Plan eligibility, adoption, funding deadlines, vesting and compensation still need independent review.

The ordinary 2027 mandatory Roth catch-up test uses 2026 sponsor Social Security wages strictly above $155,000, not the offer's current wages or household MAGI. Equality does not trigger it. The W-2 alternative separates affected Roth catch-up from pretax deductions; special employer aggregation and prior-year W-2 wages from the contractor's plan sponsor are outside this comparison. A self-employed profit figure is not automatically the required wage measure.

A self-employed health deduction is a separately verified amount bounded by paid premiums and the business earnings remaining after the half-SE adjustment and pretax retirement deduction. An amount being within those bounds does not establish monthly eligibility. Marketplace credits, subsidized-plan conflicts, Medicare, HSA/FSA and long-term-care interactions are not solved here.

Unsupported scenarios and source limits

  • Sources checked November 9, 2026 for the original worked example; retirement indexing was separately checked November 15 against Notice 2026-66. Publication 505 and Publication 15-B are 2026 editions; Publication 560 and Form 7206/8995 instructions are 2025 editions with applicable later-year information where stated. They are not certified final 2026/2027 filing-form instructions.
  • Bounded 2027 offer comparisons now use published ordinary-income, deduction, QBI, Social Security wage-base and retirement inputs. They do not borrow 2026 retirement constants, implement employer payroll withholding tables or expand to a complete household return. The worked numerical example above remains tax year 2026, even if that return is filed in 2027.
  • For the reviewed materially participating non-SSTB business, the 2026 active-QBI minimum is $400 when qualifying QBI after allocated deductions reaches $1,000; 2027 uses its separately published $415/$1,030 amounts. Section 199A(i) compares this minimum with the completed ordinary deduction after its income cap; passive income does not automatically qualify. Taxable income still cannot fall below zero.
  • Other income, credits including EITC or Saver's Credit, Saver's Match, dependents, age 65 or over, itemizing, community-property allocation, business losses, SSTBs, entities, special SE rules and Additional Medicare Tax are outside the bounded comparison. A zero-credit/benefit assumption must be independently reviewed, particularly at low income.
  • Partial plans store entered facts, not calculated results. Loading resets every review; comparing requires the same year, household, status, age and scope. Starting the next year clears amounts, age, elections and approvals and leaves the original snapshot unchanged.

Related calculators and guides

Frequently asked questions

Is $100,000 of contractor revenue the same as a $100,000 salary?

No. Contractor revenue still funds business cash costs, SE tax, insurance and the contractor's own retirement contributions. Paid versus billable time also differs. Compare actual after-cost, after-tax cash while displaying retirement assets and user benefit values separately.

Does the comparison decide whether I am an independent contractor?

No. Classification depends on the actual working relationship, including control and independence, not the preferred compensation result or the contract's label. Review the IRS classification guidance separately.

Can I load a saved offer and rely on its previous approvals?

No. Loading retains bounded inputs but resets every review. Review the current-year facts and deductions before recalculating. A new-year draft clears financial amounts and elections instead of carrying forward an old tax result.

Can I compare 2027 offers with the published retirement limits?

Yes, within the same reviewed resident-under-65, full-year, mutually exclusive offer scope. Published 2027 tax and retirement parameters are used, but credits, Saver's Match, other household income and excluded deductions or special taxes are not silently assumed supported. This is annual scenario tax, not employer withholding or a complete return.

Primary and methodology sources

Educational planning information only. Official forms, instructions, assessors, and tax agencies control your filed return or tax bill.