Tax planning guide

Backdoor Roth With an Old IRA: Track Form 8606 Basis

An old pretax rollover IRA can make a backdoor Roth conversion partly taxable even when the new contribution was nondeductible. Form 8606 generally allocates basis across one owner's traditional, traditional SEP and traditional SIMPLE IRAs, not just the converted account. Reconcile prior basis, current contributions, all year-end balances and distributions before carrying unused basis forward.

Facts required: establish the owner's basis history

  • Prior Form 8606 ending basis, source tax year and line, plus intervening contributions and distributions; a missing form is not proof of zero basis.
  • Current nondeductible contributions and their tax-year designations, including amounts contributed in the following calendar year for this tax year.
  • December 31 values of every traditional, traditional SEP and traditional SIMPLE IRA belonging to this owner, plus independently reviewed outstanding rollover adjustments.
  • Forms 1099-R and 5498, conversion confirmations, other distribution records, and evidence distinguishing deductible contributions from nondeductible basis.

Worked example: the old rollover IRA still counts

This synthetic 2026 continuity example uses the verified 2025 Form 8606 structure, not a claim of final 2026 line mapping. One living owner has no beginning basis, makes an independently eligible $6,000 nondeductible contribution before December 31, and converts $6,000. An old pretax rollover IRA is worth $54,000 at year-end. There are no earnings in the converted account, other distributions, withholding or outstanding rollovers. The $6,000 is an assumption, not an annual contribution limit.

2026 planning allocation using the 2025 Form 8606 structure
Record or calculationAmountStructural reference
Current nondeductible contribution$6,000Line 1
Beginning basis$0Line 2
Following-calendar-year contribution for this tax year$0Line 4
Available basis$6,000Lines 3 minus 4
December 31 aggregate plus rollover addback$54,000Line 6
Other distributions / conversion$0 / $6,000Lines 7 / 8
Allocation denominator$60,000Lines 6 + 7 + 8
Basis fraction10%$6,000 / $60,000
Nontaxable conversion$600$6,000 x 10%; line 11
Taxable conversion$5,400$6,000 - $600; Part II
Ending basis$5,400$6,000 - $600; line 14

Procedure: document beginning, used and ending basis

  • 1. Identify one owner and reconstruct the last reliable basis balance. Retain its source year, form and line. Reconcile intervening activity before marking even a zero balance verified.
  • 2. Enter nondeductible contributions separately from contributions made in the following calendar year for the selected year. Those later contributions can affect the basis available for the selected year's allocation; contribution year and conversion year are different facts.
  • 3. Aggregate this owner's relevant IRAs across custodians, including the old rollover IRA. Do not add a spouse's IRA or a 401(k) still held in an employer plan to this IRA balance.
  • 4. Enter nonconversion distributions separately from conversions, avoiding duplication. Add reviewed outstanding rollover adjustments to the December 31 aggregate when the instructions require them; moving money between custodians does not necessarily remove it from the calculation.
  • 5. Reconcile basis: $0 beginning + $6,000 additions - $600 used = $5,400 ending. Preserve that ending with the filed Form 8606. The continuity workspace's next-year rollover carries recalculated balances and provenance, resets review flags, and requires review again; it does not authorize another contribution.

Decision table: what must be resolved first?

Basis records are owner-specific, not account-specific
SituationConsequenceHandoff
Old pretax IRA remains at December 31New contribution is not an isolated tax-free bucketAggregate and calculate the allocation
Prior basis records missingA zero entry could overstate taxable incomeReconstruct records before calculating
Spouses both convertIRA basis remains separate for each spouseUse separate owner records and Forms 8606
Considering moving pretax IRA funds into a planPlan acceptance and rollover eligibility matterReview Publication 590-A and plan rules before acting

Important exceptions and workspace limits

The continuity workspace also requires separately reviewed capital-loss balances and return-line inputs; do not invent zeros merely to finish an IRA exercise. It blocks special IRA transactions such as excess/returned/recharacterized contributions, inherited IRAs, QCD/HSA transfers, after-tax plan roll-ins and unresolved SIMPLE restrictions. It does not determine contribution eligibility, Roth withdrawal ordering, a tax bill or a penalty.

A taxable conversion amount is income, not the tax owed. Apply the full household return separately. Rounding can differ: the workspace retains ratio precision with cumulative cent rounding; reconcile to the final form and filed return before next-year use. A conversion cannot generally be undone by recharacterizing it.

Source handoff and selected-year review

Sources checked November 9, 2026. Use Form 8606 and its instructions for the allocation, Publication 590-A for contribution/conversion rules, and Publication 590-B for distribution treatment. The linked documents are 2025 editions. Independently check selected-year instructions and line mapping for 2026 or 2027; the workspace's year selector is not proof that final forms or every retirement rule are implemented.

Related calculators and guides

Frequently asked questions

Can I convert only the nondeductible dollars?

Choosing a separate account does not bypass the owner's IRA aggregation. In this example only $600 of the $6,000 conversion uses basis.

Is the remaining $5,400 basis lost?

No. Preserve it as ending basis, subject to reconciliation and any required adjustments. It is neither a cash balance nor a tax credit.

Does this decide whether a backdoor Roth is best?

No. This is a basis-record workflow, not a recommendation about lifetime conversions or retirement outcomes.

Primary and methodology sources

Educational planning information only. Official forms, instructions, assessors, and tax agencies control your filed return or tax bill.