Tax planning guide
RSUs on W-2 and 1099-B: Check for a Basis Mismatch
Seeing RSU compensation on Form W-2 and sale proceeds on Form 1099-B does not itself mean double taxation. Reconcile the particular shares sold with their documented compensation basis. A zero or incomplete broker basis can overstate the compared capital gain, but do not assume every broker is wrong or add wages to basis twice.
Facts required: match an acquisition before changing basis
- Award type, vest and stock-delivery dates, acquired shares, FMV per share, and any amount actually paid for the shares.
- The original year's W-2 and payroll reconciliation allocating compensation and federal income-tax withholding to this vest, not the full W-2 repeated on every lot.
- Trade confirmations identifying the sold shares, gross proceeds, separately charged fees, reported basis and whether basis was reported to the IRS.
- Issuer-retained net-settlement shares, actual sell-to-cover sales and remaining shares; distinguish retained shares from real broker transactions.
Worked example: annotated synthetic 2026 records
Sources checked November 9, 2026, including the currently published 2025 editions of Publications 525 and 550. These are synthetic year-end 2026 records, not issued tax forms, broker corrections or a personal tax return. No tax rates or final 2026 filing-form release are assumed.
Assume 100 stock-settled RSUs vest and are delivered January 15, 2026 at $50 per share, with nothing paid. The assumed completed 2026 W-2 allocation includes $5,000 compensation and $1,100 federal income-tax withholding. A June 15, 2026 trade sells 40 identified shares for $2,200 gross, with $10 separate fees. Its synthetic 1099-B shows zero basis. There are no other basis adjustments; fees are not already embedded in proceeds or basis.
The $2,000 difference is a basis reconciliation, not a $2,000 refund or tax saving. Withholding is a prepayment, not another tax expense, stock basis or reduction of wages. This worksheet cannot determine whether the household's final withholding is sufficient.
| Record or calculation | Amount |
|---|---|
| Full vest compensation already on W-2 | $5,000 |
| Recorded federal withholding, a prepayment | $1,100 |
| Sale proceeds after the separate fee | $2,200 - $10 = $2,190 |
| Compared gain using reported zero basis | $2,190 |
| Reviewed sold-share basis | 40 x $50 = $2,000 |
| Reviewed short-term capital gain | $2,190 - $2,000 = $190 |
| Basis increase / change in compared gain | +$2,000 / -$2,000 |
| Unsold shares and retained basis | 60 shares / $3,000 |
Procedure: reconcile, preserve and hand off
- 1. Identify the acquisition and sale from documents, not a ticker or proceeds alone. Enter each acquisition once and each actual sale once, in date order.
- 2. Reconcile full vest compensation with its original W-2 year. For the supported same-day vest/delivery scope, basis is amount paid plus compensation. If $10 per share was paid, wages are $4,000 and total basis remains $5,000, not $6,000.
- 3. Allocate basis only to sold shares. Record a sell-to-cover transaction among sales; never add an automatic second sale or also call those same shares issuer-retained.
- 4. Check whether broker basis already includes compensation. Use the workbench for the comparison, then follow the applicable Form 8949 instructions for the reporting category and adjustment; the workbench assigns no filing code.
- 5. Retain unsold acquisition basis and prior disposal history. Restoring or rolling a browser draft forward requires fresh review; it does not create a new sale or move earlier W-2 compensation into the new year.
Decision table: a mismatch is not an automatic correction
| Observed facts | Next decision |
|---|---|
| Zero basis, documented compensation basis | Review the sold-share allocation and reporting instructions |
| Broker already shows $2,000 basis | Keep the $190 gain; do not add compensation again |
| Payroll allocation or delivery date unresolved | Ask payroll/plan administrator; use records-only mode |
| Fewer shares sold than vested | Keep unsold basis; do not use the whole vest basis against a partial sale |
Exceptions: fees, dates and unsupported awards
Fractional shares follow the same allocation: 0.1 share at $50 has $5 basis; $6 gross less $0.01 fees gives $0.99 gain. Another 0.2 share with $12 gross, $0.02 fees and $10 basis gives $1.98. Together the 0.3-share gain is $2.97, not compensation again.
Use calendar anniversaries, not a flat 365-day shortcut. A January 15, 2026 acquisition sold January 15, 2027 is still short-term; January 16 is beyond one year. A later sale retains the original compensation year. Deferred settlement, ISO/NSO, 83(b)/83(i), foreign allocation, wash sales and reorganizations require separate analysis. Ambiguous February 29 anniversaries remain records-only here.
Source handoff before filing
Keep the award, payroll allocation, trade statement and broker basis notice together. Review Publication 525 for compensation, Publication 550 for holding period and expenses, and the applicable year's Form 8949 instructions for reporting. Resolve missing wages rather than forcing a match. Neither this guide nor the workbench completes Form 8949, calculates total tax liability or establishes a withholding gap.
SYNTHETIC / INVENTED EXAMPLE
Synthetic equity records: reconcile proceeds, fees and compensation basis
Invented numbers and dates, not an actual form, notice, pay statement or client record. This is an annotated field map, not a government form replica. Nothing is automatically applied to a tool.
Assumptions and scope
- 100 stock-settled shares, $5,000 documented compensation, no cash paid, and 40 specifically identified shares sold. Ordinary U.S. RSU delivery only; no special election, cross-border or other basis adjustment.
- The $10 selling commission is already deducted in printed 1099-B proceeds. No further fee is omitted. The zero broker basis is an invented discrepancy, not a claim about every broker or an instruction to change a return.
| Document / field | Invented value | Field meaning | Review annotation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trade confirmationGross sale before commission | $2,200.00 | Trade gross is separate from the proceeds amount reported after sale commissions.[1] | Do not relabel this gross figure as the printed 1099-B box 1d amount. |
| Trade confirmationSelling commission already reflected in box 1d | $10.00 | This commission reduces the reported proceeds in this example.[1] | Do not subtract it again when starting from box 1d. Additional unincluded fees are $0. |
| 1099-BBox 1d: proceeds | $2,190.00 | Printed sale proceeds after the illustrated selling commission, not gain.[1] | Reconcile $2,200 gross less $10 commission to $2,190 reported proceeds. |
| 1099-BBox 1e: reported cost or other basis | $0.00 | Broker-reported basis, not proof of the complete compensation basis.[1] | Read covered/noncovered and reporting status; review correction/reporting instructions separately. |
| Illustrated annual W-2Box 1: total wages, tips and other compensation | $100,000.00 | Total annual compensation; not a dedicated RSU box or stock-lot basis.[2] | The separate payroll allocation below identifies the RSU portion already included here. |
| Payroll / vest supportCompensation allocated to all 100 acquired shares | $5,000.00 | Documented compensation within box 1, not $5,000 added again to wages.[3][2] | Allocate only the sold 40 shares; neither all W-2 wages nor all acquired-share basis belongs to this sale. |
Reconciliation notes
- Documented basis is $5,000 / 100 = $50 per share; the sold 40 shares have $2,000 basis. This is a manual supporting-record reconciliation, not an automatic broker correction.
- $2,190 reported proceeds - $2,000 reviewed sold-share basis = $190 gain before any other applicable adjustment. Equivalently: $2,200 trade gross - $10 commission - $2,000 basis. Subtracting the commission in both routes would be wrong. No tax/refund is computed.
Official structural sources
Checked 2026-11-09. The editions below support field meanings, not individual eligibility or a complete tax calculation.
- IRS Form 1099-B instructions: proceeds, sale commissions and reported basis2026 instructions
- IRS W-2/W-3 instructions: wage bases and federal income tax withheld2026 instructions
- IRS Publication 525: compensation and property basis2025 publication; limited structural reference, not final 2026 filing instructions
Related calculators and guides
Equity compensation lot workbench
Reconcile manually reviewed RSU/Section 423 ESPP records, W-2 allocations and sold-share basis. No total-tax or withholding-gap calculation.
ESPP compensation and gain decisions
Keep statutory ESPP holding tests separate from ordinary RSU compensation basis.
Capital-gain holding periods and reporting
Place the reconciled transaction in the wider capital-gain context; not an automatic return adjustment.
Continue with official Form 8949 instructions
Check covered/noncovered reporting and any applicable correction for the actual filing year.
Frequently asked questions
Does zero broker basis prove double taxation?
No. It flags a document comparison. Establish the acquired and sold shares and compensation basis before deciding whether a correction is needed.
Can I subtract withholding from the capital gain?
No. Federal withholding is a tax prepayment, not selling expense or basis. Keep it separate from the $190 example gain.
Does the whole W-2 amount become each sale's basis?
No. Allocate documented per-share basis to the shares sold. Do not repeat the full vest compensation or total W-2 on every sale.
Will a basis adjustment guarantee a refund?
No. The effect depends on the complete return, other gains and losses, rates, credits and payments. The workbench compares records, not final tax.
Primary and methodology sources
- IRS Publication 525 (2025): compensation basis and employee stock purchase plans
- IRS Publication 550 (2025): stock records, selling expenses and holding periods
- IRS Form 8949 instructions: reported basis and correction procedures
- IRS: federal income-tax withholding is separate from final liability
Educational planning information only. Official forms, instructions, assessors, and tax agencies control your filed return or tax bill.